southtownstar
INCONSISTENT 
Weather Updates

Reeder: ‘Puppy mill’ bill would harm reputable breeders

Scott Reeder

Scott Reeder

storyidforme: 66426519
tmspicid: 13404468
fileheaderid: 6187664

Updated: June 23, 2014 11:36AM



I love animals.

But that shouldn’t be surprising. I’m the son and husband of veterinarians.

My house is a menagerie with four dogs, two cats, two rabbits and a pair of parakeets.

Some of them are disabled. There’s the newborn kitten born without eyes that we took in, raised on a bottle and that has been a member of our family for eight years.

Or the rabbit that a client of my wife begged her to adopt after she developed allergies to her pet. And let’s not forget Lester, the St. Bernard mix, which devoured my Blackberry last month.

So the Reeder home is all about rescuing animals.

While I love animals, I have an even greater devotion to freedom. That’s why some legislation introduced recently in the Illinois Legislature gives me pause.

State Sen. Dan Kotowski, D-Park Ridge, and state Rep. Dan Burke, D-Chicago, have introduced legislation prohibiting pet stores from selling dogs that haven’t been rescued from the pound or an animal rescue group.

So much for trusting consumers to make wise decisions for themselves.

Under this bill, consumers could buy dogs from breeders, but pet stores would be prohibited from doing so. The bill’s proponents say it will cut down on so-called “puppy mills.”

Here is how the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals defines a “puppy mill” — “A large-scale, commercial dog-breeding operation that places profit over the well-being of its dogs.”

But the Illinois legislation essentially lumps all breeders into that category.

There are bad dog breeders just like there are unethical accountants, sloppy electricians, crooked cops and corrupt politicians. But most breeders, like most people in any given profession, do a good job.

Most of the dog breeders I’ve met are nice people who love animals and are committed to finding them good homes.

The federal government licenses commercial dog breeders to ensure that they are raising their animals in a safe and clean environment.

But apparently that’s not good enough for some state lawmakers. They want to throw the puppy out with its bath water.

The bill, which Gov. Pat Quinn endorses, would put some pet stores out of business.

It would also make it tougher for dog breeders, who are mostly mom-and-pop business owners. Most of the breeders I know are doing it part-time to supplement their income.

I bought Hershey, my Labrador retriever puppy, from an older woman battling muscular sclerosis and living on Social Security. Despite her physical ailments, she made sure that the dogs were clean and well cared for.

In the years after our purchase, she periodically would inquire how her “baby” was getting along.

She certainly didn’t get rich raising dogs, but it helped her make ends meet. And she found loving homes for hundreds of puppies.

But the bill before the Legislature would prohibit pet stores from buying from her.

It’s all part of that smug, government-knows-best mindset that pervades Springfield.

The “thinking” goes something like this — more dogs need to be adopted from animal shelters, so we’ll make it impossible for pet stores to sell anything but “rescue” dogs.

Never mind that it hurts small-business owners. Never mind that it reduces choices for potential pet owners.

And never mind that many of the health problems stemming from poorly run “puppy mills” also plague dog pounds and other shelters.

An animal in a pound cage can be exposed to a lot of infectious diseases.

That’s yet another reason why pet stores should be free to choose where the get their animals.

Scott Reeder is a veteran statehouse reporter and the journalist-in-residence at the Illinois Policy Institute, a nonprofit research group that supports the free market and limited government.



© 2014 Sun-Times Media, LLC. All rights reserved. This material may not be copied or distributed without permission. For more information about reprints and permissions, visit www.suntimesreprints.com. To order a reprint of this article, click here.